![]() the review site with a difference since 1999 |
||||||
| 02/09/2010 | ||||||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
|
ABC's `Modern Family' a freshman hit... The Best and Worst Super Bowl Ads... Apollo 13 (15th Anniversary Edition) on Blu-ray Apr 13... Box Office Charts From Box Office Mojo Feb 5-7... 'Avatar' dethroned at box office by 'Dear John'... PANDORUM... LOST CITY RAIDERS... GONE WITH THE WIND... PARIS, TEXAS (BLU-RAY)... THE BROTHERS BLOOM... CHE... LOUIS ARMSTRONG: GOOD EVENING, EV'RYBODY... ROBERTO ROSSELLINI'S WAR TRILOGY... THE GOLDEN AGE OF TELEVISION... GOMORRAH... ACROSS THE HALL... GIGI (BLU-RAY)... THE HUMAN CONDITION... PLASTIC MAN: THE COMPLETE COLLECTION... INTO THE STORM... THE GENERAL (BLU-RAY)... THE EXILES... GAUMONT TREASURES 1897-1913... ELVIS: THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW... DON'T BE AFRAID OF THE DARK... THE PATTY DUKE SHOW: SEASON ONE... Marie Antoinette... BERGMAN ISLAND... The Devil and Daniel Johnston... PRISON BREAK: SEASON 4... WIZARD OF OZ... WINGS OF DESIRE... HORTON HEARS A WHO!... A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS... MONSOON WEDDING... IMDb Turned 19 This Past Weekend... Rotten Tomatoes Lists The Worst of the Worst Movies of ... digitallyOBSESSED.com on iPhone... 30 ROCK SEASON 3... CRASH: THE COMPLETE FIRST SEASON... THE STEPFATHER... THE HILLS RUN RED... MANAGEMENT... NIGHT OF DEATH... GNAW... Freddy Got Fingered... The Business of Strangers... Ken Burns' America: The Congress... Aqua Teen Hunger Force: Volume Two... Touki Bouki... LAST DAYS OF DISCO... NIGHTS AND WEEKENDS... STARGATE SG-1: CHILDREN OF THE GODS... STARGATE ATLANTIS: THE COMPLETE FIFTH SEASON... Star Trek: The Motion Picture... Is the Greatest American Band: Grand Funk Railroad?... Apple Updates Remote App for iPhone... I want my Internet TV!... Pundit Opinions Duel Over Meaning of Growth on TV and V... Twitter, Brillstein develop TV series... Six Points About Inglourious Basterds (spoilers)... Secure The Second Season of The Border on DVD August 25... NFB's Behind the Camera: The ABCs of Documentary Cinema... THE SWISS FAMILY ROBINSON (1976)... NFB Blog: Documentary filmmaking from the inside out... Inside the Vault Part 2: How the NFB restores and digi... Conquest of the Planet of the Apes... Saving Private Ryan... High Noon... Film-Fest 4: Sundance 2000 & Hawaii... Me Without You... Kodo... Reflections on the Fade of Daytime's Guiding Light... HBO's Grey Gardens Explores an Inexplicable Enigma... What Happens in Vegas Diverting... Some Like It Hot... EARTH DAY: Digesting our planet... Warner offers HD-to-Blu-ray upgrades for $4.95... A Look Back: 1999... Before Night Falls... WELCOME TO THE NEW dOc!... |
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment presents "I already schooled you once tonight homeboy. How many lessons you wanna learn?"
DVD ReviewOpening with blaring music and the excited roar of the crowd, Stomp the Yard immediately thrusts you into the world of dance-offs at a popular Los Angeles club. While a group of mean-looking tough guys wows the crowd, D.J. (Columbus Short) and his brother Duron (Chris Brown) observe them and decide if it’s worth proving their superior skills. D.J. is highly confident, but his brash attitude leads to a tragic disaster. Moving to Atlanta to live with his Aunt Jackie (Valarie Pettiford) and Uncle Nate (Harry J. Lennix), D.J. tries to forget the past and enrolls at Truth University. The young man still has a huge chip on his shoulder, however, and it could lead to more trouble. Will D.J. be able to discover the “truth” and deal with his inner turmoil?Thankfully, the grand tradition of African-American fraternities and the team-oriented benefits of stepping exist to help D.J. overcome his difficulties. This plot-heavy story includes love, fraternity conflicts, family history, and numerous dance sequences within nearly two hours of running time. While the excessive length gives us the chance to truly get to know D.J. and the other key figures, it also includes too many standard plot elements and predictable turns that lessen the overall impact. One of the main stories involves D.J.’s romantic interest in April (Meagan Good)—an attractive young girl who’s also the daughter of the dean. She currently dates fraternity step star Grant (Darrin Dewitt Henson), which complicates matters considerably. Short and Good create worthy characters and we want them to get together, but Henson's villain is so obvious that it lessens the excitement. Grant represents the typical affluent jock who doesn’t appreciate the great girl and shows arrogance at every turn. D.J.’s friendly, loose approach quickly draws April's attention, creating a serious conflict with the angry frat guys. This description involves only a small portion of this overloaded story, which also presents an extremely positive depiction of African-American fraternities. I’m not denying they can play a very positive role in a young man’s life, but several scenes treat the institutions like hallowed sanctuaries. A key sequence involves D.J.’s visit to Heritage Hall, where he views pictures of major figures like Martin Luther King Jr., Michael Jordan and Rosa Parks while exploring the history of Truth’s Greek system. This event’s strong effect on him is completely understandable, but Director Sylvain White (I Always Know What You Did Last Summer) presents the subject with such reverence that any subtlety disappears. Even hazing is glossed over quickly and virtually ignored as a non-issue. I did not expect White and Writer Robert Adetuyi to explore this troubling issue; this is not that type of film. However, the lengthy speeches about “brotherhood for life” become a bit groan-inducing when presented from such a one-sided approach. One area where the film excels is with the unique dance sequences involving complex moves and enjoyable face-offs. Chris Brown does impressive work in the opening scene, and Short delivers numerous worthy moments throughout the picture. The action culminates in the lengthy national championships, which grow a bit ridiculous near the end but contain some exciting material. Director of Photography Scott Kevan presents these sequences with a kinetic, music-video style that almost appears separate from the primary story. This approach helps to crank up the energy, but it also pulls us out of the other conflicts. They often feel like filler between the dance numbers, which creates an uneven tone. The non-dance scenes utilize a deliberate, emotional score that sometimes works but also is overplayed. I admire the intentions and Short keeps us engaged, but White’s directing style is a bit too blatant for my tastes. I’m only mildly familiar with stepping due to the involvement of a college roommate in the mid-‘90s. The intricately choreographed dances have grown in popularity since that time, and Stomp the Yard will almost certainly cause more people to explore stepping. The film was a sleeper hit this past spring and does showcase talented young actors performing enjoyable dances. The downside is the subpar plot, which grows tedious and becomes especially mundane during the twists of its second hour. On its most basic level, D.J.’s story is inspiring, but it would have been even more effective if the obstacles had felt more grounded in reality instead of the standard movie conflicts. Rating for Style: B- Rating for Substance: C Image Transfer
Image Transfer Review: Stomp the Yard contains many high-flying dance sequences, and the 2.40:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer presents these moments effectively. The best visual scenes involve the shots of the empty pool, which create a unique training environment. The presentation is a bit dark and grainy at times, but it fails to detract too much from the overall experience. The music-video style of the finale's step routines spring well from the screen and deliver the necessary energy. Image Transfer Grade: B+ Audio Transfer
Audio Transfer Review: This release includes a condsiderable amount of music, particularly during the club scenes and dance routines, and the 5.1-channel Dolby Digital transfer does a nice job presenting the audio. It's not a groundbreaking technical achievement that you'll be playing for friends, but the sounds are powerful enough to sell the story. The rear speakers also receive significant use and help to complement the primary audio. This disc also provides a solid 2.0-channel French transfer that should please any francophiles viewing this release. Audio Transfer Grade: B+ Disc ExtrasFull Motion menuScene Access with 28 cues Subtitles/Captions in English, French, Spanish with remote access 9 Other Trailer(s) featuring Crossover, Rocky Balboa, Surf's Up, Across the Universe, Little Man, Gridiron Gang, You Got Served, The Gospel, Are We Done Yet? 3 Deleted Scenes 1 Documentaries 1 Featurette(s) 1 Feature/Episode commentary by Director Sylvain White, Editor David Checel, and Cinematographer Scott Kevan Packaging: unknown keepcase Picture Disc 1 Disc 1-Sided disc(s) Layers: dual Extra Extras:
This release also provides three deleted/extended scenes and a gag reel, which add little worthy information. The extra footage last about six minutes and includes a longer version of the opening dance sequence, split into two segments. Both Chris Brown and the female dancers get a chance to shine during these moments. The other scene involves Columbus Short and his frat brothers making an impromptu song while cleaning up the yard. The gag reel falls just short of two minutes and has the standard clips of people laughing, falling down, and being silly during shooting. Extras Grade: B Final CommentsStomp the Yard offers mild entertainment and a few interesting extras, but the overall effect is pretty underwhelming. If you're interested in step or just love dance movies, this release might be a good choice. However, the uneven tone and conventional plot twists lessen the drama and my enthusiasm. |
|
| Become a Reviewer | Search | Review Vault | Reviewers Readers | Webmasters | Privacy | Contact |
||||
|
|